You could also use orange or peppermint extract if you prefer one of them and have them on hand too, though they aren't as traditional. Can you use cookie cutters for Italian Christmas cookies?

These chocolate-dipped Italian pistachio biscotti are ... Pistachio Biscotti This easy Lebkuchen recipe makes traditional German Christmas cookies. Soft and cake-like, they’re filled with ...

According to the results, Italian Christmas cookies dominate much of the U.S., with seven states searching for them. The basic treat is distinguished by its almond extract glaze and round ...